Stanley Crouch and percussionist James Mtume on the evolution of modern jazz

Beneath the Spin * Eric L. Wattree

Reflections on the Stanley Crouch, Mtume Debate on Modern Jazz
.
.

I recently watched the debate between columnist Stanley Crouch and percussionist James Mtume on the evolution of modern jazz with great interest. Crouch, the steadfast jazz purist, essentially took the position that much of what’s passing for jazz today is actually a corruption of the art form, while Mtume took the position that Crouch was simply out of touch with the new face of jazz.
.
In my opinion, Stanley Crouch was right, and James Mtume was simply remaining consistent with what his musical philosophy seems to advocate – playing to the audience and giving applause priority over substance. But Crouch made the mistake of not framing the issue in a way that would allow him to sieze the bottom line. It’s not about the new versus the old; what the discussion is actually about is quality versus lesser quality, and that can be measured.
.
First, just because something is new doesn’t mean that it’s better. The problem with a lot of electronic music is electronics is being used to camouflage a lack of technical competence. There’s so much noise and electronic distortion going on that it gives the musicians the “freedom” to play bad notes, be less than melodic, and play musical nonsense. Where, on the other hand, acoustic music is intimate. It’s purely about the musician and his technical ability. Period. If Bud Powell played a bad note, or played the wrong chord progression, it would stick out like a soar thumb. But if he was playing electronic music there’s so much chaos and distortion going on that nobody would notice.

For more

Advertisements

About TruthWorks Network

TruthWorks Network The Black Voice Collaborative Live and Call-In Talk Radio Talk radio engaging in discussions and providing informed knowledge of contemporary world political events and issues. Presentation of ideas, research and scholarship as a basis of analysis. Informed dialogue, hosted by knowledgeable and experienced voices. This is serious talk radio, focusing on TALK THAT MATTERS. The Black Voice Collaborative on Blog Talk Radio. Presenting some of the best more concise voices which examine, analyze and explore issues about and for the Black community. From insightful and in-depth with scholars and activist to authentic discussion about Black families, relationships and children, to “just damn push-back political smackdown” . . . Discover YourSelf on Truthworks Network. Truth Works Network A broadcast product of OUR COMMON GROUND COMMUNICATIONS LLC

Posted on July 23, 2012, in Music and the Arts, Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink. Leave a comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s